Coronavirus: EU top scientist forced out in political row - BBC NewsAction.News ABC Action News Santa Barbara Calgary WestNet-HD Weather Traffic

Home WestNet.ca WebMail

              

Coronavirus Information: Buy Masks Here

Coronavirus: EU top scientist forced out in political row - BBC News


Posted: Fri-Jun-2020



Mauro Ferrari says he lost faith in the system, but EU science officials say he was asked to leave.

The president of the European Union's ERC scientific research council has resigned after three months in the job with an attack on the EU's scientific governance and political operations.

Mauro Ferrari said he had lost faith in the system after he failed to set up a special programme to fight coronavirus.

But the research council said later his resignation followed a written, unanimous vote of no confidence.

It said it regretted Prof Ferrari's comments.

"Since his appointment, Professor Ferrari displayed a lack of engagement with the ERC, failing to participate in many important meetings, spending extensive time in the USA and failing to defend the ERC's programme and mission when representing the ERC," it said in a statement.

The EU's executive insisted it had the most comprehensive measures to combat the virus.

One MEP had earlier been quoted accusing Prof Ferrari of taking a "window-dressing public relations stand".

Who is Mauro Ferrari?

Mauro Ferrari is an Italian-American scientist known as a pioneer in the field of nanomedicine with decades of work in the US. When he took up the role as head of the European Research Council he stressed his commitment to serving society.

In a statement to the Financial Times and Corriere della Sera in Italy, he spoke of his commitment to the "idealistic dream of a United Europe... crushed by a very different reality".

As the tragedy of the pandemic became clear Prof Ferrari says he pushed for a special programme directed at combating Covid-19, with the world's best scientists having the resources to fight it with new drugs, vaccines, diagnostic tools and behavioural approaches based on sciences "to replace the oft-improvised intuitions of political leaders".

His proposals were rejected unanimously, he said, by the council's governing body because the ERC funded "bottom-up" research proposed by scientists themselves and did not see the beneficial impact on society as a justification for funding.

Prof Ferrari describes how he then worked directly with European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and developed a plan which she contributed to.

However, he complains his direct involvement with Mrs von der Leyen "created an internal political thunderstorm" and once it went to the different parts of the Commission he believes it "disintegrated upon impact".

There are many questions surrounding the real reasons behind the resignation of Mauro Ferrari.

Yes, his stinging accusations about EU institutions weighed down by bureaucracy and internal politics ring true, but he will have known that before he agreed to become the bloc's chief scientist.

He will have also known that EU countries have always fought to keep sovereignty over national health services, so it is odd that he singled the lack of public health co-ordination across the EU as another reason for his departure.

Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption Prof Ferrari said he had worked directly with Ursula von der Leyen

In fact, high-level insiders in the European Research agency tell me Mr Ferrari's resignation was not voluntary. He was asked to leave, they say.

They say he was absent for half of the three months he was supposedly at the helm of the ERC, spending time instead in the US, where he has an affiliate professorship at the University of Washington as well as private interests in the pharmaceutical industry. He is listed on the board of directors at US biotech company Arrowhead Pharmaceuticals.

Mauro Ferrari announced he was now returning to the US to fight Covid-19 on the front line.

The ERC is eager to point out that many of its top scientists have already done that. It says virologists, epidemiologists and others who were doing basic research for them have now joined Covid research teams in other European Commission programmes.

Professor Ferrari's personal ambitions clashed with the cumbersome structures of the EU, perhaps. A crying shame on all sides when all hands are needed on deck in Europe, the US and globally to help protect the general public from coronavirus.

The research council detailed several of those points in its statement, saying:

  • Prof Ferrari had failed to take part in important meetings and spent extensive time in the US
  • he had made several personal initiatives within the Commission, without consulting or tapping into the ERC's collective knowledge
  • he had been involved in multiple external enterprises, some academic and some commercial, which "appeared on several occasions to take precedence over his commitment to ERC"
  • his workload proved to be incompatible with his mandate.

Speaking to the BBC's Newshour programme on Wednesday, Prof Ferrari said his departure was caused by a "very significant divergence of opinion" about the strategy needed for the current crisis. He also denied his other work commitments hindered his ability to fulfil the role.

The EU has often struggled to reach a consensus on tackling the Covid-19 outbreak. Finance ministers suspended talks early on Wednesday on how to help southern eurozone countries worst affected by the pandemic. The talks were due to resume on Thursday.

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionThe BBC’s Gavin Lee took a road trip in Europe's Schengen area to see how free movement has changed

After Prof Ferrari's resignation, German MEP Christian Ehler told the Science Business website that Prof Ferrari's proposals contradicted the legal basis of the ERC and were a "window-dressing public relations stand on the coronavirus crisis".

One of the conditions for an ERC grant is that scientists apply for funding on a "bottom-up" basis for research either in a public or private research organisation.

A Commission spokesman said more 50 ERC projects had been involved in fighting the Covid-19 pandemic and 18 research and development proposals had been selected.- across a variety of scientific fields from virology to social behaviour.

Prof Ferrari said it was time for him to return to "the frontlines of the fight against Covid-19, with real resources and responsibilities, away from offices in Brussels, where my political skills are clearly inadequate".

The Commission said it was grateful for Prof Ferrari's "strong personal investment" and wished him well for the future.

Headlines:
Hong Kong Outlaws Insulting China's National Anthem
Pro-democracy lawmakers see the anthem bill as an infringement of freedom of expression, and staged a protest in the legislative chamber. ... read more


German Man Identified As Suspect In Case Of Missing UK Girl Madeleine McCann
The long-running case of McCann, who vanished in Portugal shortly before her fourth birthday, has intrigued Britain for years. ... read more


Security Guard Reportedly Injures 39 In Knife Attack At Chinese Kindergarten
The motive remains unknown. ... read more


Coronavirus Live Updates: Read The Latest About The COVID-19 Outbreak
Stay up to date as we cover the ongoing coronavirus pandemic and its effects across the world. ... read more


Matt Hancock’s ‘Misleading’ Testing Figures Slammed By UK Stats Watchdog
Health secretary told current figures are neither "complete" nor "comprehensible". ... read more


BAME People Are More Likely To Die Of Coronavirus Than White People
Public Health England report finds people of Bangladeshi ethnicity are twice as likely to die as white people, while other minority groups had a 10 to 50% higher risk. ... read more


Italy Marks Historic Turning Point In The Coronavirus Pandemic
The country that was once the global epicenter of COVID-19 is lifting travel restrictions, hoping to be at the vanguard of a post-virus recovery. ... read more


China Delayed Releasing Coronavirus Info, Frustrating WHO: AP Report
The AP has found rather than colluding with China, WHO was itself largely kept in the dark, as China gave it only the minimal information required. ... read more


Congo Faces 2nd Ebola Outbreak In Northern Province
The health crisis comes as the African country battles COVID-19 and the world’s largest measles outbreak. ... read more


Left Without Work In The Lockdown, This Car Cleaner Became A TikTok Dance Sensation
Arman’s dancing was limited to local competitions and weddings until social media turned him into a celebrity. ... read more


Lockdown Trapped Women In Violent Relationships. Their Abusers Might Kill Them When It Ends
Domestic abuse campaigners have warned women could die if abusive men lash out as coronavirus restrictions are lifted. ... read more


Europe’s Landmark Coronavirus Package Puts Divisions Aside
While America’s response to the pandemic has been mired in partisan squabbling, European leaders have rallied around an economic rescue plan. ... read more


Coronavirus Live Updates: Read The Latest About The COVID-19 Outbreak
Stay up to date as we cover the ongoing coronavirus pandemic and its effects across the world. ... read more


Hong Kong Police Reject Application For Tiananmen Square Vigil
Police said the vigil would violate coronavirus social distancing rules. ... read more


Anti-Racism Protesters Around The World Demand Justice For George Floyd
Hundreds of demonstrators gathered in London, Berlin and Copenhagen over the weekend, chanting "Black lives matter" and "say his name." ... read more


11 Amazing Photos You Missed This Week
Scenes from Memorial Day, protests in Minneapolis and Hong Kong, and life during the coronavirus round out this week's best images. ... read more


Trump: U.S. Is Terminating Relationship With World Health Organization
Trump said the U.S. would be “redirecting” money to “other worldwide and deserving urgent global public health needs,” without providing specifics. ... read more


Coronavirus Live Updates: Read The Latest About The COVID-19 Outbreak
Stay up to date as we cover the ongoing coronavirus pandemic and its effects across the world. ... read more


Rich Torontonians Eyeing An Exodus From City After Pandemic: Agency
The shift to working from home opens up possibilities, especially for wealthier people. ... read more


Europe’s Grand Reopening Begins With a Whimper
Hopes that reopening restaurants and bars would provide an economic boost have been dashed as customers stay away and businesses fight for survival. ... read more


Madeleine McCann 'assumed dead' by German prosecutors
A German man, 43, is being investigated on suspicion of murder over the British girl’s disappearance. ... read more


Eurozone in fresh emergency action to boost economy
The central bank will increase the size of its bond buying programme by €600bn (£546bn) to €1.35tn. ... read more


Prague Catholic statue torn down by mob rises again
A controversial statue of the Virgin Mary erected in the 17th Century is hoisted back in Prague. ... read more


Norway landslide: Buildings swept away in Alta disaster
Watch as land continues to collapse during the rescue effort. ... read more


Arctic Circle oil spill prompts Putin to declare state of emergency
A power plant manager is arrested after 20,000 tonnes of oil polluted an Arctic river. ... read more


Diego Costa: Atletico Madrid forward fined for tax fraud, avoids prison time
The Atletico Madrid forward is fined €543,208 (£485,324) for defrauding the state of over €1m. ... read more


German stimulus package hands families €300 for each child
The one-off payment is part of a series of measures to boost an economy hit by the coronavirus crisis. ... read more


BA refuses to meet Home Secretary over quarantine plans
The airline has declined to meet Priti Patel amid strong criticism of the UK's quarantine policy. ... read more


Porn star Nacho Vidal held in Spain after man dies in toad-venom ritual
Spanish police investigate Nacho Vidal over the death of a man who inhaled a psychedelic substance. ... read more


Coronavirus: 'No judgement' over lockdown mountain rescues
Hillwalkers should not be concerned about calling 999 for help, Scottish Mountain Rescue say. ... read more


Coronavirus: Italy's Conte offers hope as travel restrictions end
Italy ends travel restrictions almost three months after lockdown measures began. ... read more


The 100-year wound that Hungary cannot forget
Hungary lost two-thirds of its territory in the 1920 Trianon treaty and now aims to revive its past. ... read more


Madeleine McCann case in pictures
Photographs of some of the key moments since the three-year-old went missing in Portugal in 2007. ... read more


Coronavirus: How lockdown is being lifted across Europe
As the UK alters its restrictions, how are other European countries reopening after lockdown? ... read more


'My brothers on Europe's last death row'
Any day now two men may be executed in Europe's only country that still has the death penalty. ... read more


Coronavirus: Would a new Irish government lift lockdown faster?
As government formation talks continue, there are indications the Covid-19 recovery plan may accelerate. ... read more


What's French club rugby really like? Ben Mercer reveals all
Eye-gouging, drinking on the job, offloads and under-the-radar stars. Ben Mercer on his four years in a rugby culture like no other. ... read more


UK's big zoos at risk of closure
The Covid crisis is putting the survival of one of the UK's largest zoos at risk. ... read more


Coronavirus in Russia: 'I don't trust Putin any more'
In Russia, coronavirus has seen the long-time president's approval rating fall to an all-time low. ... read more


Coronavirus: Is Putin's relaxing of restrictions for political gain?
Russia's coronavirus infection rate is one of the highest but tight restrictions are beginning to be lifted. ... read more


Protesters say they face tough choice amid pandemic: The 'lives of our unborn sons' or 'those of our parents'
“In many ways we’re choosing between the lives of our unborn sons and those of our parents," one protest organizer said. ... read more


Ex-Minneapolis cop told other officers 'you shouldn't do this' during George Floyd's arrest, lawyer says
Attorneys for two of the officers, charged with aiding and abetting murder, claimed the men tried to express concern during Floyd's deadly arrest. ... read more


Buffalo police officers suspended after video shows them pushing protester
Buffalo Mayor Byron Brown said he was "deeply disturbed" by the video of a 75-year-old man being knocked to the ground during a protest. ... read more


NYPD officers could face suspension over clashes with protesters, commissioner says
Dermot Shea pleaded with politicians to camm their rhetoric against officers, who have been shot at and stabbed. ... read more


Why the charges against Derek Chauvin were upgraded
Legal analysis: Under the charges, prosecutors don't have to prove former Officer Derek Chauvin intended to kill George Floyd. ... read more


Black Lives Matter sues Trump administration over use of force on D.C. protesters
Black Lives Matter and the American Civil Liberty Union allege that the administration violated the protesters' civil rights. ... read more


Floyd family attorney Benjamin Crump gives stirring memorial speech
"We cannot cooperate with injustice. We cannot cooperate with torture, because George Floyd deserved better than that," Benjamin Crump said. ... read more


Soldiers called to Washington, D.C., may soon be going home, says senior defense official
More than 700 soldiers from the Army's 82nd Airborne are going back to Fort Bragg on Thursday night, and hundreds of MPs from Fort Drum could go home Friday. ... read more


GOP Sen. Grassley holding up Trump nominations until he gets answers on IG firings
The Iowa Republican is placing holds on two nominations until Trump can explain why he ousted a pair of government watchdogs. ... read more


Trump expected to keep Esper on
The president was so angry with Esper's comments about his church visit, he had told aides he was considering dismissing the defense secretary. ... read more


First came a pandemic. Then, looting. Small businesses pick up the pieces as their debt mounts.
“I did feel violated, but what do you do? You clean up the glass and open the door and try to keep serving the community,” said one small-business owner. ... read more


The law lets bad police off the hook. Here's how to make them pay — literally
Our current laws provide impunity for bad cops — and even in the rare cases they're held liable, taxpayers foot the bill. ... read more


Gabrielle Union files discrimination complaint against 'America's Got Talent' producers
Union's complaint arrives a week after she spoke out publicly for the first time about her experience on the NBC show. ... read more


Social media posts help feds arrest those committing violence at Floyd protests
DOJ is urging U.S. attorneys to use federal courts — where more serious charges are available — for prosecutions. ... read more


Prosecutors say she tried to firebomb an NYPD van. Her friends say she's a 'regular girl'
Samantha Shader was allegedly captured on video tossing a Molotov cocktail at a police van with four officers inside. ... read more


Enraged New York driver who chased protesters with blades attached to arm is arrested
Video shows a man speeding after a group of young protesters in his SUV, then rushing them with blades strapped to his arm. ... read more


Supreme Court blocks order to remove inmates at prison infected with COVID-19
The ACLU said one-fifth of the inmate population at Elkton Federal Correctional Institution in Ohio is infected. ... read more


Large hydroxychloroquine study is retracted
"A first-year statistics major could tell you about major flaws in the design of the analysis," one expert said. ... read more


Drew Brees' biggest mistake? Believing the American flag means anything
Colin Kaeperneck asked his country to think about its own symbols, rather than blindly worship them. Brees, and white Americans in general, have not risen to this challenge. ... read more


NBA owners approve tentative July 31 restart to season with just 22 teams playing
All games of the virus-shortened seasoned would be played near Orlando, Florida, according to the plan. ... read more


https://media1.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3379216/200604-new-york-george-floyd-protest-ppe-se-318p_d493c355f6b80b062c39e60fec3e9f8e.jpg
Protesters say they face tough choice amid pandemic: The 'lives of our unborn sons' or 'those of our parents'
“In many ways we’re choosing between the lives of our unborn sons and those of our parents," one protest organizer said. ... read more


https://media3.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3377881/200603-2x1-keirnan-lane-thomas-alexander-kueng-tou-thao-ew-713p_8efdf424ec469ddb6318bad9f98dc5bf.jpg
Ex-Minneapolis cop told other officers 'you shouldn't do this' during George Floyd's arrest, lawyer says
Attorneys for two of the officers, charged with aiding and abetting murder, claimed the men tried to express concern during Floyd's deadly arrest. ... read more


https://media3.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3379846/200604-niagra-square-police-protester-face-blurred-ac-1056p_09581f129f654cc23aed3c02270d5c6e.jpg
Buffalo police officers suspended after video shows them pushing protester
Buffalo Mayor Byron Brown said he was "deeply disturbed" by the video of a 75-year-old man being knocked to the ground during a protest. ... read more


https://media2.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3379731/200604-new-york-nypd-protest-ac-911p_76b7b1f1b4c1c266695eb1718218b7fd.jpg
NYPD officers could face suspension over clashes with protesters, commissioner says
Dermot Shea pleaded with politicians to camm their rhetoric against officers, who have been shot at and stabbed. ... read more


https://media4.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3377431/200603-derek-chauvin-mugshot-2x1-se-331p_5d7f62f9f449c6a5d524a2bb29dbf003.jpg
Why the charges against Derek Chauvin were upgraded
Legal analysis: Under the charges, prosecutors don't have to prove former Officer Derek Chauvin intended to kill George Floyd. ... read more


https://media4.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3374216/200601-washington-dc-protest-police-clash-baton-ac-811p_f745a408516308b5c8d8f252b33c31bb.jpg
Black Lives Matter sues Trump administration over use of force on D.C. protesters
Black Lives Matter and the American Civil Liberty Union allege that the administration violated the protesters' civil rights. ... read more


https://media12.s-nbcnews.com/i/MSNBC/Components/Video/202006/crump.jpg
Floyd family attorney Benjamin Crump gives stirring memorial speech
"We cannot cooperate with injustice. We cannot cooperate with torture, because George Floyd deserved better than that," Benjamin Crump said. ... read more


https://media2.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3379351/200604-soldiers-protest-washington-se-413p_221fdbeafd07e2d45c99527ce0e34e1c.jpg
Soldiers called to Washington, D.C., may soon be going home, says senior defense official
More than 700 soldiers from the Army's 82nd Airborne are going back to Fort Bragg on Thursday night, and hundreds of MPs from Fort Drum could go home Friday. ... read more


https://media3.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3379081/200604-chuck-grassley-ew-202p_1e9964889713c435e4f3213173ba5ced.jpg
GOP Sen. Grassley holding up Trump nominations until he gets answers on IG firings
The Iowa Republican is placing holds on two nominations until Trump can explain why he ousted a pair of government watchdogs. ... read more


https://media2.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3379266/200604-mark-esper-se-333p_5fd7cff945918ace1e995e35366644ca.jpg
Trump expected to keep Esper on
The president was so angry with Esper's comments about his church visit, he had told aides he was considering dismissing the defense secretary. ... read more


https://media4.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3377171/200603-protest-damaged-small-business-express-food-mart-chicago-se-122p_aba732ac242be811feeca6c264f8bfe7.jpg
First came a pandemic. Then, looting. Small businesses pick up the pieces as their debt mounts.
“I did feel violated, but what do you do? You clean up the glass and open the door and try to keep serving the community,” said one small-business owner. ... read more


https://media2.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3378266/200603-seattle-police-baton-line-force-ac-1159p_57716e89023382463fb3d9d5bb9cb0f6.jpg
The law lets bad police off the hook. Here's how to make them pay — literally
Our current laws provide impunity for bad cops — and even in the rare cases they're held liable, taxpayers foot the bill. ... read more


https://media4.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3379326/200604-gabrielle-union-amerias-got-talent-se-405p_f5c6fb99d00a7475fbf7b99379ecc27e.jpg
Gabrielle Union files discrimination complaint against 'America's Got Talent' producers
Union's complaint arrives a week after she spoke out publicly for the first time about her experience on the NBC show. ... read more


https://media2.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3378911/100604-protests-damage-minneapolis-se-1200p_8b6b9c802010dcf616209d762d47f8d5.jpg
Social media posts help feds arrest those committing violence at Floyd protests
DOJ is urging U.S. attorneys to use federal courts — where more serious charges are available — for prosecutions. ... read more


https://media4.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3375631/200602-samantha-shader-cover-ac-515p_0adf0aa008aaae7d7ac475f25a13ad54.jpg
Prosecutors say she tried to firebomb an NYPD van. Her friends say she's a 'regular girl'
Samantha Shader was allegedly captured on video tossing a Molotov cocktail at a police van with four officers inside. ... read more


https://media3.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3379576/200604-man-knives-car-queens-snip-ac-720p_31c342ea7f7f1b60ece5cc7544d153ac.jpg
Enraged New York driver who chased protesters with blades attached to arm is arrested
Video shows a man speeding after a group of young protesters in his SUV, then rushing them with blades strapped to his arm. ... read more


https://media3.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3379541/200604-elkton-federal-correctional-ew-655p_f9a69f04741b52a29cca1aa55ab2350f.jpg
Supreme Court blocks order to remove inmates at prison infected with COVID-19
The ACLU said one-fifth of the inmate population at Elkton Federal Correctional Institution in Ohio is infected. ... read more


https://media1.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_22/3312881/200417-plaquinol-hydroxychloroquine-ew-1113a_b68789960f723d4cbf3f5ac57dad84f9.jpg
Large hydroxychloroquine study is retracted
"A first-year statistics major could tell you about major flaws in the design of the analysis," one expert said. ... read more


https://media1.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3378841/200604-think-drew-brees-kneel-before-national-anthem-ew-1119a_96064f656e38351c1cdd245acc1c73d3.jpg
Drew Brees' biggest mistake? Believing the American flag means anything
Colin Kaeperneck asked his country to think about its own symbols, rather than blindly worship them. Brees, and white Americans in general, have not risen to this challenge. ... read more


https://media1.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3377181/200603-nba-mn-1345_c532be98c5fd60ccb6fa7247859f27a4.jpg
NBA owners approve tentative July 31 restart to season with just 22 teams playing
All games of the virus-shortened seasoned would be played near Orlando, Florida, according to the plan. ... read more


https://media4.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3379726/200604-joe-biden-snip-ac-905p_8826a7cd6be0839c268779d4b4ef20a4.jpghttps://media1.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3379621/200604-capital-crescent-trail-maryland-cover-ac-738p_9359bd8549d66d0ee0fbf1c2b8371921.jpghttps://media3.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3379576/200604-man-knives-car-queens-snip-ac-720p_31c342ea7f7f1b60ece5cc7544d153ac.jpghttps://media2.s-nbcnews.com/i/newscms/2020_23/3378966/200604-jean-stothert-se-1239p_ec8e7cfa78acb0d701b97bfdc9c989ee.jpg